Gapping and comparative ellipsis
Gapping leaves out a repeated verb in the second part of a sentence: Some chose tea, others coffee. (= others chose coffee) Comparative ellipsis leaves out words after than and as: It was harder than (I had) expected. Gapping is mostly formal and written; comparative ellipsis is common in speech and writing alike.
Gapping
- Anna plays the violin, and Tom the piano.
- I ordered fish; my wife, pasta. (a comma can mark the gap)
- One student wrote 500 words, another only 50.
Only when the verb is the same
The verb you leave out must be the same verb in the same tense. The person can change: I live in Paris, and my sister in Rome. (= lives) If the tenses differ, keep both verbs: I live in Paris, and my sister lived in Rome.
Gapping works only between clauses joined by and, or or a comma or semicolon, not after because, although, when: Anna plays the violin because Tom the piano. The gap is always in the second clause: Anna the violin, and Tom plays the piano.
After than and as
| Full | Shortened |
|---|---|
| more people than we had expected | more people than expected |
| as soon as it is possible | as soon as possible |
| better than it was before | better than before |
| more than was necessary | more than necessary |
Than me or than I?
In everyday English use the object pronoun: She’s taller than me. Than I on its own sounds stiff; in formal writing add the verb: taller than I am. Watch the double meaning: I trust you more than him (than I trust him) vs I trust you more than he does.
Other common ellipsis
- ➕After and / but / orShe came in and (she) sat down. We can stay or (we can) go.
- ❓Wh-word aloneSomeone called, but I don’t know who. (= who called)
- 🔁After a helping verbI can’t swim, but my brother can. (see Leaving words out)
Check yourself
Leave words out
Shorten: Tom drinks coffee and Sara drinks tea.
Tom drinks coffee and Sara tea.
Shorten: The meeting lasted longer than we had planned.
… longer than planned.
Shorten: Something happened, but I don’t know what happened.
… but I don’t know what.
Gapping and ellipsis exercises
Practise what you have just read. Every test has answers with explanations and a printable PDF.
Questions
What is gapping?
Leaving out a repeated verb in the second part of a sentence: Anna plays the violin, and Tom the piano.
What does “more than expected” leave out?
More than (we had) expected.
When can I use gapping?
Only when the verb left out is the same verb in the same tense: I live in Paris and my sister in Rome (= lives).
Finished this lesson?
Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the grammar lessons page.
Questions and comments