Present perfect or past simple? The difference, with exercises

Level: A2–B1 · 3 exercises with answers · Save

On this page
  1. The key question: is the time finished?
  2. Five ways to choose
  3. 1. A finished time word, or none?
  4. 2. Experience or a specific event?
  5. 3. Still true, or finished?
  6. 4. Is the person alive, is the period open?
  7. 5. News: new, then details
  8. Time words at a glance
  9. Common mistakes
  10. Check yourself

Use the past simple when the time is finished or stated: I saw that film last week. Use the present perfect when the time is not given or not finished, or the past connects with now: I’ve seen that film. I’ve lived here since 2019.

The key question: is the time finished?

Past simple

subject+verb-ed / 2nd form+finished time

I lost my keys yesterday.

Present perfect

subject+have / has+3rd form+(unfinished time)

I’ve lost my keys. (I still can’t find them.)

  • subject
  • main verb
  • helping verb
  • time word
past simplepresent perfect

pastfuture

The past simple is a finished point in the past. The present perfect reaches up to now.

The full forms are in Past simple and Present perfect, and the past participles are in Regular and irregular verbs. This lesson is about choosing.

Five ways to choose

1. A finished time word, or none?

Past simple: finished time

  • yesterday, last week, in 2015, two days ago, when I was ten
  • We met in 2015.

Present perfect: no time / unfinished time

  • ever, never, just, already, yet, so far, today, this week
  • We’ve already met.

2. Experience or a specific event?

Present perfect: life experience

  • Have you ever been to India?
  • I’ve climbed Mount Fuji.

Past simple: the details

  • When did you go?
  • I climbed it in 2018. It took eight hours.

The usual pattern: start a topic with the present perfect, then give details in the past simple.

3. Still true, or finished?

Present perfect: still true

  • She’s worked here for ten years. (She still works here.)

Past simple: over

  • She worked here for ten years. (She left.)

Advertisement

4. Is the person alive, is the period open?

Present perfect

  • I’ve written three emails this morning. (It’s still morning.)
  • Spielberg has made many films. (He can still make more.)

Past simple

  • I wrote three emails this morning. (It’s now the afternoon.)
  • Hitchcock made many films. (He died in 1980.)

5. News: new, then details

Scientists have discovered a new planet. (news) They saw it with a new telescope last month. (details)

Time words at a glance

Past simplePresent perfectBoth (meaning changes)
yesterday, last…, … agoever, nevertoday, this week (perfect if not finished)
in 2010, in May, at 3 o’clockjust, already, yetfor (perfect = still true; past = finished)
when…? / when I was…since, so far, recentlybefore

American English

Americans often use the past simple with just, already and yet: Did you eat yet? I just saw him. British English: Have you eaten yet? I’ve just seen him. Both are correct; British exams expect the present perfect.

Common mistakes

  • I have seen him yesterday.I saw him yesterday.
  • When have you arrived?When did you arrive?
  • I know her since 2010.I’ve known her since 2010.
  • Did you ever see a whale? (BrE)Have you ever seen a whale?
  • Shakespeare has written 37 plays.Shakespeare wrote 37 plays. (He is dead.)

Check yourself

Past simple or present perfect?

I ___ (finish) my homework. Can I go out now?

I’ve finished: result now.

I ___ (finish) my homework an hour ago.

I finished: ago = finished time.

___ you ever ___ (try) Thai food?

Have you ever tried: experience.

Where ___ you ___ (buy) that jacket?

Where did you buy: a specific past event.

My grandfather ___ (be) a teacher for 40 years. He retired in 2010.

was: finished.

We ___ (live) here since 2015.

have lived: still true.

Easy to remember

The past simple is a closed box in the past: you know when, and it’s over. The present perfect is an open door from the past into now.

Present perfect or past simple? exercises

Practise what you have just read. Every test has answers with explanations and a printable PDF.

More tenses tests →

Questions

When do I use the past simple instead of the present perfect?

Use the past simple when you say or know the finished time: yesterday, last week, in 2010, two days ago. Use the present perfect when the time is not given or not finished: ever, never, this week, so far.

Can I say "I have seen him yesterday"?

No. Yesterday is a finished time, so use the past simple: "I saw him yesterday."

Do Americans use the present perfect less?

Yes. Americans often say "Did you eat yet?" where British speakers say "Have you eaten yet?" Both are correct in their own variety.

Finished this lesson?

Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the grammar lessons page.

Advertisement

Questions and comments