Shall I? Shall we? Offers and suggestions

Level: A2 · Save

On this page
  1. How to form it
  2. Answering
  3. Other ways to say it
  4. Common mistakes
  5. Check yourself

Shall I…? offers to do something for someone: Shall I open the window? Shall we…? makes a suggestion: Shall we go out tonight? Both are common in British English. Americans usually say Should I…?, Do you want me to…? or Let’s….

How to form it

Offer

ShallI+base verb…?

Shall I carry your bag?

Suggestion

Shallwe+base verb…?

Shall we take a taxi?

Asking for ideas

Wh-shallI / we+base verb…?

What shall we do this evening?
Where shall I put this?

  • shall
  • I / we
  • base verb

Mostly I and we

In offers and suggestions, shall goes with I and we. Don’t say Shall you…? (In formal British English you may also hear Shall he come in?, meaning “Do you want him to…?”.)

Answering

QuestionYesNo
Shall I help you?Yes, please. That’s very kind.No, thanks. I’m fine.
Shall we go for a walk?Yes, let’s! / Good idea!I’d rather not. / Maybe later.

Other ways to say it

  • 🙋OffersShall I make dinner? = Do you want me to make dinner? = I’ll make dinner, shall I?
  • 💡SuggestionsShall we go? = Let’s go. = Why don’t we go? = How about going?
  • 🏷️Question tag after let’sLet’s order pizza, shall we? See Question tags.

American English

Shall sounds formal or old-fashioned to most Americans. They say Should I open the window? and Should we go? or Let’s go.

Shall in statements

I shall / we shall for the future is now rare and formal; most people say I will / I’ll. In rules and contracts, shall means “must”: The tenant shall pay the rent monthly.

Advertisement

Common mistakes

  • Shall I to open the door?Shall I open the door?
  • Do I open the window? (an offer)Shall I open the window?
  • Shall you help me?Will / Could you help me?
  • Do we go now? (a suggestion)Shall we go now?

Check yourself

Offer or suggest with shall

Your friend’s bag looks heavy. (offer)

Shall I carry your bag?

You and a friend are bored. (suggest a film)

Shall we watch a film?

You don’t know where to meet. (ask)

Where shall we meet?

Add the tag: “Let’s start, ___?”

shall we

Say it the American way: “Shall I call a taxi?”

Should I call a taxi? / Do you want me to call a taxi?

Shall I? Shall we? exercises

More modals tests →

Questions

What does Shall I…? mean?

It offers to do something for someone: Shall I carry your bag?

How do you answer Shall we…?

Yes, let's! / Good idea! or No, I'd rather not.

Do Americans use shall?

Rarely. They usually say Should I…?, Do you want me to…? or Let's….

Finished this lesson?

Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the grammar lessons page.

Advertisement

Questions and comments