Academic words 4: argument and opinion (assume, valid, justify)

Level: C1 · 1 exercise with answers · Save

On this page
  1. Ideas and how you read them
  2. Objective or subjective?
  3. Is the argument any good?
  4. Attack and defence
  5. Wrong ✗ / Right ✓
  6. A tutor’s notes on an essay: “Should city zoos close?”
  7. Check yourself

These 17 academic words help you build an argument, judge someone else’s and attack or defend a position.

Remember these?

You know perspective and contradict from Word roots: spect, port, dict, graph, compelling evidence from Reviews: arts, books and performances, bias from The press and the media take into account from Opinions and beliefs, infer and imply from Commonly confused words 5: advanced pairs and a sweeping generalisation from Collocations 7: strong, fixed and weak.

Advertisement

Ideas and how you read them

  • concept/ˈkɒn.sept/nounA general idea you can name and discuss, such as fairness, time or “home”. You can’t touch it.Small children find the concept of money surprisingly hard.
  • assume/əˈsjuːm/verbYou think something is true, but you haven’t checked. The noun: an assumption.I assumed the car park was free, so I didn’t bring any cash.
  • interpret/ɪnˈtɜː.prɪt/verbYou decide what data, a poem or someone’s silence really means.She interpreted his short reply as anger, but he was only busy.
  • stance/stɑːns/nounThe public position you take on a question, like the way you stand in a fight: take a stance on.The club has taken a firm stance on racist behaviour by fans.
  • objective/əbˈdʒek.tɪv/adjectiveBased on facts that anyone can check, not on your feelings.It’s hard to be objective about your own child’s painting.
  • subjective/səbˈdʒek.tɪv/adjectiveIt depends on who is judging: taste, feelings, personal experience. Not wrong, just personal.Whether a joke is funny is completely subjective.

Objective or subjective?

📏 objective

  • anyone can check it
  • The bus leaves at 8.10.

❤️ subjective

  • it depends on the judge
  • That bus is always annoying.

Quick test: could you check it with a clock, a ruler or a price tag? Then it’s objective.

Is the argument any good?

  • valid/ˈvæl.ɪd/adjectiveA point that is reasonable and deserves an answer. A valid passport or card still counts.You make a valid point about the cost, but think about the benefits.
  • coherent/kəʊˈhɪə.rənt/adjectiveEvery part connects to the next, so the reader can follow. The opposite is incoherent.Her essay is coherent: each paragraph leads to the next.
  • plausible/ˈplɔː.zə.bəl/adjectiveIt could easily be true, so people believe it. Not proved, just believable. The opposite: implausible.The film’s ending isn’t very plausible: nobody survives a fall like that.
  • credible/ˈkred.ə.bəl/adjectiveYou can trust it enough to take it seriously: a credible source, a credible witness. Careful: incredible usually means amazing.A blog run by the company itself is hardly a credible source.
  • flawed/flɔːd/adjectiveLike a vase with a crack: it looks fine, but there is a weak spot that spoils it. The noun: a flaw.The survey was flawed: only fans of the band answered it.
  • controversial/ˌkɒn.trəˈvɜː.ʃəl/adjectiveMention it at dinner and people start to argue. The noun: controversy.The new parking charges are highly controversial.
  • justify/ˈdʒʌs.tɪ.faɪ/verbYou give good reasons why a choice or a claim is right. Your boss may ask you to justify an expense.How can they justify a 20% rise in ticket prices?

Advertisement

  • justifyverb
  • justificationnoun
  • justifiableadjective

Attack and defence

  • undermine/ˌʌn.dəˈmaɪn/verbLike loosening one brick at the bottom of a wall: you slowly make an argument or someone’s confidence weaker.One wrong date in the report undermined everything else in it.
  • reinforce/ˌriː.ɪnˈfɔːs/verbYou add support, so an idea or a feeling becomes stronger. Builders reinforce walls with steel.The new study reinforces what nurses have said for years.
  • refute/rɪˈfjuːt/verb formalYou show with evidence that a claim is wrong. Saying “no, it isn’t” is only denying it, so without proof write deny or reject.The museum refuted the story with photos of the painting from 1950.
  • counterargument/ˈkaʊn.tər.ɑː.ɡjə.mənt/nounThe best reason against your own view. Good essays answer it.The obvious counterargument is that buses are cheaper than trams.

Word partners

  • make an assumption / a false assumption
  • a key concept / grasp a concept
  • open to interpretation
  • take a stance on / a firm stance
  • a valid point / a valid passport
  • a credible source / witness
  • fundamentally flawed
  • highly controversial
  • seriously undermine

Wrong ✗ / Right ✓

  • The manager assumed her mistake and said sorry.The manager admitted her mistake. (Spanish asumir, French assumer: take responsibility.)
  • His actions are not coherent with his words.His actions are not consistent with his words. (Spanish coherente con, French cohérent avec)
  • Immigration is a very polemic topic.Immigration is a very controversial topic. (Spanish polémico, German polemisch; English polemic is a rare noun for a fierce attack.)
  • She took a stance for the four-day week.She took a stance on the four-day week. (or: argued for it)

Advertisement

A tutor’s notes on an essay: “Should city zoos close?”

Dear Malik, this is a coherent essay with a clear stance: you want city zoos to close. Your first paragraph explains the concept of animal welfare well. Some of your points are valid, especially the one about space.

However, the second section is flawed. You assume that every zoo keeps animals in small cages, which is a sweeping generalisation. You also interpret the visitor figures as proof that people have lost interest; I infer the opposite from the same table. Your explanation is plausible but not proved.

Add the obvious counterargument: zoos breed rare species. Then refute it with evidence, or admit it and justify your view anyway. Words like “cruel” are subjective; numbers are more objective. One wrong source can undermine a whole essay, so check that each one is credible; a good quotation will reinforce your conclusion. A controversial topic needs that extra care. Mark: 64%.

Check yourself

Try first. Then tap.

Spot the mistake: The two witnesses gave incoherent stories, so the police believed them.

Coherent (or consistent). Nobody believes stories that don’t make sense.

Credible or incredible? “The witness was ___: she was sober, close by and had no reason to lie.”

Credible: we can believe her. Incredible means amazing, or too strange to believe.

Make it a noun: “The decision was highly controversial.” The decision caused a lot of …

controversy: The decision caused a lot of controversy.

Which verb goes with concept? Many four-year-olds can’t yet ___ the concept of time.

grasp (understand): you grasp a concept, as if you take hold of it.

Plausible or flawed? A plan that sounds right but has one serious weakness.

flawed: plausible things sound believable; flawed ones have a weak spot.

For teachers

Pairs swap a short opinion paragraph. Each partner writes two comments with the words: one that reinforces the argument and one that undermines it.

Academic words 4: argument and opinion exercises

Practise what you have just read. Every test has answers with explanations and a printable PDF.

QuizC1Academic wordsPDF

Academic Words for Argument Quiz: Assume, Valid, Justify, Refute

15 questions · about 6 min

More academic words tests →

Questions

What is the difference between plausible and valid?

A plausible claim sounds believable, but nobody has proved it. A valid point is reasonable and deserves an answer; a valid passport or card still counts.

Does refute mean the same as deny?

Not in careful writing. To refute a claim is to prove it wrong with evidence. To deny it is only to say it is not true. Many people now use refute for deny, but examiners still prefer the difference.

What is the difference between objective and subjective?

An objective statement rests on facts that anyone can check, such as height or price. A subjective one depends on the person judging, such as taste or feelings.

Finished this lesson?

Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the vocabulary lessons page.

Advertisement

Questions and comments