Advanced modal forms
On this page
At the highest level, modals carry subtle meanings: short modal perfects in replies (“Where’s Tom?” “Must have gone home.”), stressed will for disapproval (He WILL leave the door open), would for typical behaviour (She would say that, wouldn’t she?), should for surprise (Who should I meet but my old teacher!), and the difference between needn’t have and didn’t need to.
Shortened modal perfects
In speech, the subject can disappear in short replies:
- “Where are my keys?” “Must have left them in the car.”
- “Did she get the job?” “Might have. I don’t know.”
- “I failed.” “Should have studied, then!”
Full forms: Should have, might have, would have.
Would: “that’s typical”
- “He said the report was excellent.” “Well, he would say that. He wrote it.”
- It would rain on my wedding day! (annoyed: of course it did)
- I’d have thought you’d be pleased. (polite surprise or disagreement: I expected you to be pleased, and you aren’t)
Stressed will and would for habits: Will and would for habits.
Might have, could have: complaining
- You might have told me you were coming! (you didn’t, and I’m annoyed)
- He could have at least said thank you.
- I might have known he’d be late. (= typical; I’m not surprised)
More modal phrases: May well, might as well.
Should for surprise and in that-clauses
- 😲SurpriseI was walking down the street, and who should I see but Anna!
- 🤔After it’s strange / odd / a pity thatIt’s odd that he should say that. (emotional reaction)
- 🎩Should = if (formal)Should you need help, call me. (see Inversion)
Needn’t have or didn’t need to?
Needn’t have done
- I needn’t have bought milk. (I bought it, but it wasn’t necessary)
Didn’t need to do
- I didn’t need to buy milk. (it wasn’t necessary; usually I didn’t buy it)
More in Needn’t have and didn’t need to.
Common mistakes
She mustn’t have heard me.(a deduction)She can’t have / couldn’t have heard me. (American English also uses must not have)I needn’t to have worried.I needn’t have worried.
Check yourself
Advanced modal meanings
Short reply: “Why is the floor wet?” “___ been raining in.” (certain deduction)
Must have
What does would show? “She would complain, wouldn’t she?”
It’s typical of her (the speaker is not surprised, a little annoyed).
I took a taxi, but the station was very close. I ___ (need / take) a taxi.
needn’t have taken (didn’t need to take is also possible)
Formal: If you have any questions, please ask. (Should …)
Should you have any questions, please ask.
Advanced modal forms exercises
Practise what you have just read. Every test has answers with explanations and a printable PDF.
Questions
What does “He would say that” mean?
It is typical of him; the speaker is not surprised and may doubt him.
Can I answer just “Must have”?
Yes, in speech: Where’s Tom? Must have gone home.
What does “Should you need help” mean?
If you need help. It is formal.
Finished this lesson?
Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the grammar lessons page.
Questions and comments