Modals of deduction: must, might, can’t
On this page
When we make a guess based on evidence, we use modals of deduction. must = I’m almost sure it’s true; might / may / could = it’s possibly true; can’t = I’m almost sure it’s not true. He’s been working all day. He must be tired. That can’t be Tom; he’s in Paris.
How sure are you?
- 95%must
- 50%might · may · could
- 5%can’t
subject+must / might / could / can’t+be / base verb
She must be at home. The lights are on.
They might know the answer.
subject+must / might / can’t+be + -ing
The phone’s busy. He must be talking to someone.
- subject
- modal
- verb
The evidence and the guess
| Evidence | Deduction |
|---|---|
| She’s wearing a wedding ring. | She must be married. |
| He’s not answering his phone. | He might be asleep. / He could be driving. |
| That bag costs £5. | It can’t be real leather. |
| Someone’s at the door. I’m waiting for Anna. | That may be Anna. |
The opposite of must
can’t, not mustn’t
For a negative deduction, use can’t (or couldn’t): You’ve just eaten. You can’t be hungry! Mustn’t means “not allowed”, so You mustn’t be hungry is wrong here. (In American English, must not is sometimes used for deduction: He must not be home.)
could or can?
For a possibility about one situation now, use could, not can: Where’s Tom? He could be in the garden. (not He can be in the garden)
About the past (B2)
For guesses about the past, use the modal + have + past participle: She must have forgotten. He can’t have seen us. See Should have, might have, would have.
Common mistakes
He must to be tired.He must be tired.That mustn’t be true.(deduction)That can’t be true.She can be at work now.(a guess)She could / might be at work now.They must are rich.They must be rich.
Check yourself
must, might or can’t?
He’s running a marathon tomorrow. He ___ be very fit.
must
She ___ be 40! She looks about 20.
can’t
I’m not sure where my keys are. They ___ be in the car.
might (or may / could)
Listen! Someone’s playing the piano. It ___ be Emma; she’s the only one who plays.
must
Correct it: “That can be your bag. Yours is red.”
That can’t be your bag.
Modals of deduction exercises
Practise what you have just read. Every test has answers with explanations and a printable PDF.
QuizB1ModalsPDF
Modals of Probability (Present) MCQ Grammar Quiz – Test – Exercise
18 questions · about 7 min
QuizB1ModalsPDF
MAY and MIGHT (Possibility) MCQ Grammar Quiz – Test – Exercise
18 questions · about 7 min
Questions
What is the opposite of must be?
Can't be: You've just eaten. You can't be hungry.
Can I say mustn't be for deduction?
Not in British English. Mustn't means not allowed. Use can't.
What is the difference between might and must?
Must means you are almost sure; might means it is possible.
Finished this lesson?
Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the grammar lessons page.
Questions and comments