Non-defining relative clauses; which or that?

Level: B1 · 2 exercises with answers · Save

On this page
  1. Defining or non-defining?
  2. The rules
  3. Which for a whole sentence
  4. Which or that?
  5. Common mistakes
  6. Check yourself

A non-defining relative clause adds extra information about someone or something we have already identified: My sister, who lives in Leeds, is a nurse. It goes between commas, you can’t use that, and you can’t leave out who or which. If you remove it, the sentence still makes complete sense.

Defining or non-defining?

Defining: which one?

  • The students who passed got a certificate.
  • Only the students who passed. Essential information.
  • No commas; that is possible.

Non-defining: extra information

  • The students, who passed, got a certificate.
  • All the students passed. Extra information.
  • Commas; no that.

The commas change the meaning! In speech, we show them with small pauses.

The rules

  • ✏️Use commas (or one comma at the end)Paris, which is the capital of France, is beautiful. / I met Tom, who works with my dad.
  • 🚫No “that”My car, which is ten years old, still runs well. (not , that is ten years old,)
  • 🔒Never leave out who / whichThe film, which I saw last week, was great. (not The film, I saw last week, was great.)
  • 🏷️Often after names and unique thingsMount Everest, which…; my mother, who… (there’s only one)

Which for a whole sentence

Which can refer back to the whole previous idea: He passed all his exams, which surprised everyone. (= the fact that he passed surprised everyone)

Which or that?

Clause typewhichthat
Defining (no commas)✓ the car which I bought✓ the car that I bought (more common in speech)
Non-defining (commas)✓ my car, which I bought…✗ never

A style habit

Many American style guides prefer that for defining clauses and keep which for non-defining ones. British English uses both which and that freely in defining clauses.

Advertisement

Common mistakes

  • My brother, that is a doctor, lives abroad.My brother, who is a doctor, lives abroad.
  • London which is huge is expensive.London, which is huge, is expensive.
  • She lost her keys, what was annoying.She lost her keys, which was annoying.

Check yourself

Add who or which (and commas)

My grandmother still swims every day. She is 90.

My grandmother, who is 90, still swims every day.

The Thames flows through London. It is 346 km long.

The Thames, which is 346 km long, flows through London.

It rained all weekend. This ruined our plans.

It rained all weekend, which ruined our plans.

Can you use that? “My phone, ___ I bought last year, is broken.”

No: use which (non-defining).

Non-defining relative clauses exercises

Practise what you have just read. Every test has answers with explanations and a printable PDF.

QuizB1Relative clausesPDF

Relative Clauses MCQ Grammar Quiz – Test – Exercise

16 questions · about 6 min

QuizB1Adverbial clausesPDF

Clauses Test B1 Grammar Exercises

20 questions · about 7 min

More relative clauses tests →

Questions

What is a non-defining relative clause?

A clause that adds extra information, between commas: My sister, who lives in Leeds, is a nurse.

Can I use that in a non-defining clause?

No. Use who or which: My car, which is old, still runs well.

Do commas change the meaning?

Yes. The students who passed means only some students; The students, who passed, means all of them passed.

Finished this lesson?

Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the grammar lessons page.

Advertisement

Questions and comments