The subjunctive and should in that-clauses
On this page
After verbs and adjectives of demand, suggestion and importance (insist, recommend, essential), formal English can use the subjunctive: the base form of the verb for every person, with no ‑s and no tense change. They insisted that he be present. It’s essential that she arrive on time. British English often uses should instead: … that she should arrive on time.
The pattern
insist / suggest / essential …+that+subject+base verb
We recommend that he see a doctor.
… that+subject+should+verb
We recommend that he should see a doctor.
- subject
- should
- base verb
No ‑s, no past
It is vital that he attend (not attends). They demanded that she leave (in formal English, not left; informal British English sometimes uses a normal tense). Negative: that he not be told (no don’t). Passive: We ask that all bags be left at the desk.
Words that trigger it
| Type | Words |
|---|---|
| Verbs | insist, suggest, recommend, propose, demand, request, ask, require, urge |
| Adjectives (It is … that) | essential, vital, important, necessary, crucial, imperative |
| Nouns | the suggestion / recommendation / requirement / demand that … |
Only for demands, not facts
When insist or suggest reports a fact or opinion, use a normal tense: She insisted that she had locked the door. (= said firmly) The evidence suggests that he was there.
British and American English
🇺🇸 American: subjunctive
- I suggest that he take a break.
- Normal even in everyday writing.
🇬🇧 British: should, or a normal tense
- I suggest that he should take a break.
- Informal: I suggest he takes a break.
- The subjunctive is used in formal British writing.
Suggest has its own patterns
Suggest + person + to-infinitive is wrong: I suggest him to rest. Use I suggest (that) he rest / rests / should rest or I suggest resting. See Reporting verbs.
Fixed phrases
- If I were you, … (the past subjunctive; see If I were you)
- God save the King. Long live the King.
- Be that as it may, … Come what may, … (C2)
- So be it. Suffice it to say …
Common mistakes
The doctor recommended that she rests.(fine in informal British English, but too informal for formal writing)… that she rest / should rest. (rests is fine in informal British English)It is essential that he doesn’t know.(too informal for formal writing)It is essential that he not know / should not know.They insisted me to pay.They insisted that I pay / on my paying.I want that you come.(from Spanish quiero que, French je veux que)I want you to come. (want and would like don’t take a that-clause)
Check yourself
Formal English
The manager insisted that every employee ___ (attend) the meeting.
attend (or should attend)
It is vital that the report ___ (be) finished by Friday.
be (or should be)
Negative: They requested that we ___ (not / smoke) inside.
not smoke (or should not smoke)
Correct it: I suggest you to see a doctor.
I suggest (that) you see a doctor. / I suggest seeing a doctor.
The subjunctive exercises
Practise what you have just read. Every test has answers with explanations and a printable PDF.
QuizC1Mixed grammar
The Subjunctive Quiz: Insist That He Be, Essential That
15 questions · about 6 min
Questions
What is the subjunctive?
The base form of the verb for every person after words of demand or importance: It’s essential that she arrive on time.
Do British speakers use the subjunctive?
In formal writing, yes. British English often uses should (that she should arrive) or a normal tense in informal English.
Can I say “I suggest him to rest”?
No. Say I suggest (that) he rest / rests / should rest, or I suggest resting.
Finished this lesson?
Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the grammar lessons page.
Questions and comments