Tense choice in reporting

Level: C1 · 1 exercise with answers · Save

On this page
  1. Three tenses, three messages
  2. Reporting verbs and attitude
  3. Spoken reporting: no backshift needed
  4. Modals in reporting
  5. Common mistakes
  6. Check yourself

When we report what writers, researchers or speakers say, the tense is a choice, not just a rule. Academic writing often uses the present for ideas that still stand (Smith argues that …), the past for a specific study or event (Jones found that …), and the present perfect for research up to now (Several studies have shown …).

Three tenses, three messages

TenseUse · Example
Present simplethe idea is still valid or discussed
Darwin suggests that species change slowly.
Past simpleone study, a finished event
In 2019, a team in Oslo tested 200 children.
Present perfecta body of research up to now
Many researchers have argued that …

Distance through tense

Choosing the past can show that you don’t fully accept an idea or that it is out of date: Early scientists believed that the sun moved round the earth. The present shows you treat it as part of the current debate.

Reporting verbs and attitude

The reporting verb also shows how you see the claim:

  • 😐Neutralsays, states, notes, explains, describes, reports
  • 👍You agreeshows, demonstrates, establishes (the claim is true; proves is very strong and rare in academic writing)
  • 🤔Tentativesuggests, implies, proposes, speculates
  • 🧐You doubt itclaims, asserts, alleges (it may not be true)

More reporting verbs and their patterns: Reporting verbs.

Spoken reporting: no backshift needed

In everyday speech, if what was said is still true, you don’t have to change the tense:

  • She told me she lives in Bristol. (she still does) or … she lived in Bristol.
  • He said the shop opens at nine.
  • But backshift when it is no longer true or you don’t believe it: He said he was a doctor, but he isn’t.

Advertisement

See Reported speech for the basic rules.

Modals in reporting

DirectReported
“I will / can / may help.”She said she would / could / might help.
“You must leave.”He said I must / had to leave.
“You should / ought to rest.”The doctor said I should / ought to rest. (no change)
“I would / could / might …”no change

Common mistakes

  • In 2015, Lee has found that sleep improves memory.In 2015, Lee found that sleep improves memory. (a past date needs the past simple)
  • The author claims that the earth is round. (grammatically fine, but claims suggests doubt about a known fact)The author notes that the earth is round.
  • According to Smith, he argues that …According to Smith, … / Smith argues that … (not both)

Check yourself

Choose the tense or verb

Several studies ___ (link) diet to mood. (research up to now)

have linked

In a 2015 experiment, Lee ___ (ask) 50 people to keep a diary.

asked

Orwell ___ (argue) that clear language leads to clear thinking. (an idea still discussed)

argues

You doubt the claim: The company ___ that its product is safe. (claims / demonstrates)

claims

Tense choice in reporting exercises

Practise what you have just read. Every test has answers with explanations and a printable PDF.

QuizC1Reported speech

Tense Choice in Reporting Quiz: Argues, Found, Have Shown

15 questions · about 6 min

More reported speech tests →

Questions

Why do academics write “Smith argues”?

The present shows the idea is still part of the current discussion.

When do I use the present perfect in reporting?

For a body of research up to now: Several studies have shown that…

What is the difference between claims and shows?

Shows means you accept it is true; claims suggests it may not be true.

Finished this lesson?

Mark it as studied when you understand it and have tried the exercises. Your progress shows on the grammar lessons page.

Advertisement

Questions and comments